Musketeer Madness

Thad Matta!!! Very cool for Butler fans. Matta's an excellent coach, probably second best (behind Miller) of all the coaches I have seen at Xavier (since 1984).

"Everything Old Is New Again"

Big East coaches
Jay Wright
Sean Miller
Thadd Matta,
Shocka Smart
Ed Cooley
Mike Anderson
Dan Hurley
Greg McDermott
Tony Stubblefield
Patrick Ewing
Shaheen Holloway

Impressive list

Is it possible that we had a chance at Matta and we went with Miller and his baggage?

Swing and a miss if so.

Here's hoping Matta's health hold out... Dan

xaviermuskie2003 wrote: ↑

Sun Apr 03, 2022 8:06 pm

Is it possible that we had a chance at Matta and we went with Miller and his baggage?

Swing and a miss if so.

are you for real?

Matta has MAYBE 5 years left coaching at most. Butler is grooming him to be AD there when he's done. i bet he has about 3 and then he becomes the AD.

Xavier didn't SNIFF Matta for this. He was not the right guy at his age, etc to take over this Xavier program.

why don't you just give Sean a chance before you just throw him and Xavier under the bus for this hire?

let's see how it all plays out.

Matta will be the loudest boo of the season at Cintas when Butler comes to play. Doubt anyone forgives his straight out lies when he bolted to OSU. There's a long list of successful XU coaches that took bigger jobs (Gillen, Prosser, Miller, Mack). But none of them lied about it and snuck out the back door in the middle of the night.

XU Rocks! wrote: ↑

Mon Apr 04, 2022 10:08 am

Matta will be the loudest boo of the season at Cintas when Butler comes to play. Doubt anyone forgives his straight out lies when he bolted to OSU. There's a long list of successful XU coaches that took bigger jobs (Gillen, Prosser, Miller, Mack). But none of them lied about it and snuck out the back door in the middle of the night.

Yeah that will be a fun game to be at.

longliveskip wrote: ↑

Mon Apr 04, 2022 7:53 am

xaviermuskie2003 wrote: ↑

Sun Apr 03, 2022 8:06 pm

Is it possible that we had a chance at Matta and we went with Miller and his baggage?

Swing and a miss if so.

are you for real?

Matta has MAYBE 5 years left coaching at most. Butler is grooming him to be AD there when he's done. i bet he has about 3 and then he becomes the AD.

Butler may be grooming him for the AD position but he is only 54 years old. Sean is 53 so why is it that Matta has MAYBE 5 years and not Sean?

muskieman wrote: ↑

Mon Apr 04, 2022 12:17 pm

longliveskip wrote: ↑

Mon Apr 04, 2022 7:53 am

xaviermuskie2003 wrote: ↑

Sun Apr 03, 2022 8:06 pm

Is it possible that we had a chance at Matta and we went with Miller and his baggage?

Swing and a miss if so.

are you for real?

Matta has MAYBE 5 years left coaching at most. Butler is grooming him to be AD there when he's done. i bet he has about 3 and then he becomes the AD.

Butler may be grooming him for the AD position but he is only 54 years old. Sean is 53 so why is it that Matta has MAYBE 5 years and not Sean?

Spot on Muskieman. Well done.

They are the same age.

Miller was fired from his last job and has NCAA troubles. Many around college hoops view him as toxic.

Matta has the health questions for sure. But he also has final fours and a National Championship game appearance.

Matta > Miller. By a long shot.